What Debts Can Be Included in a Debt Management Plan and Which Ones Cannot?
If you’re exploring debt relief options, you may wonder what debts can be included in a debt management plan (DMP) and which usually fall outside its scope. A DMP is designed to simplify repayment by consolidating multiple debts into a single monthly payment, often with reduced interest rates. However, not every type of debt qualifies, so it’s important to understand where the line is drawn.
Most debts eligible for enrollment in a debt management plan are unsecured. These are debts that aren’t tied to collateral, such as a home or vehicle, making creditors more open to adjusting terms. Common examples include:
- Credit card balances with high interest rates
- Store cards or retail charge accounts
- Personal loans not backed by collateral
- Collection accounts related to unpaid unsecured bills
- Old utility bills that have gone into collections
- Medical debts that have been transferred to third-party collectors
Adding these into a DMP can create a clearer path forward by consolidating payments, lowering interest rates, and helping you pay off balances faster than by making minimum payments alone.
What Debts Aren’t Covered By Debt Management Programs?
On the other hand, there are debts not covered by debt management programs. These are often secured debts or obligations with legal restrictions, meaning creditors are less flexible about negotiating terms. Examples include:
- Mortgages and home equity loans, since missing payments could risk foreclosure
- Auto loans or title loans, where the vehicle is collateral
- Federal student loans, although some private student loans may qualify
- Tax debts owed to the IRS or state agencies
- Court-ordered obligations such as child support or alimony
- Payday loans, in some cases, depending on the lender’s policies
The difference comes down to whether the debt is unsecured or secured. Unsecured debt is not secured by any property and is more likely to be included. Secured debt is linked to an asset, so missing payments could result in losing that property, which is why it’s excluded from most programs.
In short, DMPs are designed to handle unsecured debts, giving you structure and relief without putting your home, car, or other valuable assets at risk.
How Is Debt Management Different from Debt Consolidation or Settlement?
If you’re weighing options for handling debt, you’ve probably asked, “What is the difference between debt management and debt settlement?” Both approaches aim to relieve financial stress but take very different paths.
Many people also wonder how debt management is different from debt consolidation. Understanding how these three strategies compare will help you see the benefits and drawbacks more clearly before making a decision.
When looking at debt management versus debt consolidation, a debt management plan (DMP) is arranged through a credit counseling agency, like Debt Reduction Services. Instead of borrowing more money, the agency works with your creditors to:
- Reduce interest rates
- Waive certain late fees or penalties
- Combine multiple bills into one monthly payment
Debt consolidation, by contrast, involves taking out a new loan or line of credit to pay off your existing balances. Some of the key differences include:
- Debt management does not involve taking on new credit, whereas consolidation typically requires it.
- A DMP lowers costs through creditor negotiations; consolidation depends entirely on the terms of your new loan.
- Consolidation often requires strong credit to secure a low interest rate.
- A consolidation loan may extend repayment over a longer period, resulting in higher total costs over time.
The comparison between debt management and debt settlement highlights even sharper contrasts. Settlement companies attempt to negotiate lump-sum payoffs for less than the amount owed. While this can reduce your balances, it often comes with major downsides:
- Serious damage to your credit score
- Negative marks that remain on your report for years
- Possible tax liability on forgiven debt
Debt management, on the other hand, requires you to repay your debts in full, but under more manageable terms. Because you continue paying, the impact on your credit is far less harmful compared to a settlement.
Considering the pros and cons of debt management versus consolidation can also guide your choice. A DMP may be best if you want lower interest rates, structured support, and accountability without adding new loans.
In short, all three strategies can help reduce debt, but the outcomes differ significantly. Debt management provides steady repayment with reduced costs, consolidation restructures balances under one new loan, and settlement lowers the total owed—at the expense of your long-term credit health.
Related Resources
Call Now to Speak with a Certified Debt Relief Counselor
Does a Debt Management Plan Hurt Your Credit Score, and If So, for How Long?
Many people worry and wonder, “Does debt management hurt your credit?” The answer is that it can—at least in the beginning. A debt management plan (DMP) often causes a small dip in your score, but the long-term effects are usually positive.
When you ask, “Do debt management plans hurt your credit?” The biggest factor is what happens when you first enroll. Most plans require you to close or suspend your credit card accounts. That lowers your available credit, changes your utilization ratio, and may lower your score. Creditors can also note in your file that your accounts are being repaid through a plan.
These changes may sound intimidating, but they are temporary. As soon as you begin making steady payments, your credit starts to recover. Payment history is the most important part of your credit score, and a DMP helps you build a record of consistent, on-time payments.
Here’s what to expect:
- Early on: Closing accounts and restructuring debt may lower your score.
- While in the plan: Each on-time payment strengthens your credit profile.
- Over time: Lower balances and a positive payment history often improve your score before the plan even ends.
So, does a debt management plan affect your credit score? Yes—but your actions while enrolled matter more than the plan itself. If you stay on track, avoid late payments, and commit to the program, your credit can recover faster than you might think.
Most people see the dip last only for the first several months. As debts shrink and repayment histories grow, the benefits outweigh the drawbacks. For many, a DMP is the first step toward stronger credit and lasting financial stability.
Related Resources
Success Stories
Is Debt Management Better Than Bankruptcy for Long-Term Financial Health?
Many people facing overwhelming balances ask, “Is debt management better than bankruptcy?” The answer depends on your financial situation, but the long-term consequences of each option are very different.
With debt management, you continue paying back what you owe under adjusted terms. This approach requires patience but often leaves you in a stronger position over time. Some of the long-term effects include:
- Repaying debts in full while lowering interest rates and fees.
- Experiencing a small dip in your credit score at first when accounts are closed.
- Building positive payment history as you make consistent on-time payments.
- Gradually improving your credit by the time the plan is complete.
- Showing creditors that you are committed to repayment which can help when seeking future loans.
On the other hand, bankruptcy offers faster relief by erasing certain debts, but it also carries lasting drawbacks. Its long-term effects often include:
- Discharging many unsecured debts quickly, providing immediate relief
- Leaving a serious negative mark on your credit report for 7 to 10 years
- Making it harder to qualify for loans, mortgages, or even some types of employment
- Causing a steep drop in your credit score that takes years to recover from
- Limiting financial opportunities long after the bankruptcy case is closed
The credit impact of debt management compared to bankruptcy highlights why many people opt for repayment whenever possible. Debt management may temporarily lower your credit score, but making steady payments allows for a gradual recovery. Bankruptcy delivers immediate relief but casts a long shadow over your financial future.
When choosing between bankruptcy and a debt management plan, the right option depends on your ability to make reduced payments. If you can afford to repay under new terms, debt management is often the healthier long-term choice. Bankruptcy should generally be considered a last resort when repayment is no longer realistic.
Related Resources
